Where the parties stand

October 24, 2001
Issue 

Coalition

  • Heavily regulate migration, with a strong emphasis on money and skills.

  • Wind back allocation for family reunion and humanitarian entrants.

  • Maintain a cap on overall migration, with the effect of around 1% overall population increase per year.

  • Punish and deter those who try to migrate or seek refuge outside the "proper channels", including mandatory detention without trial and temporary second-class visas for refugees who enter "illegally".

Labor

  • Has no substantial differences from the Coalition.

  • Keep mandatory detention. Punish asylum seekers who arrive unauthorised.

  • Ensure Australia's immigration intake reflects the needs of business.

  • Establish an Office of Population Policy.

  • Establish stronger links with Indonesia, and greater regional cooperation, to solve the issue of people smuggling and unauthorised arrivals.

  • Appoint a Special Australian Representative to promote regional action on people smuggling, to reflect Australia's seriousness.

  • Establish a Coast Guard, "a cop on the beat 52 weeks of the year".

  • Increase Australia's contribution to the UN High Commission for Refugees (currently $20 million a year).

Democrats

  • End mandatory detention, instead favouring reception centres to determine identity, provide health checks.

  • Extend permanent residence to all those found to be refugees, oppose temporary protection visas.

  • Institute community-based arrangements for asylum seekers while claims being processed.

  • Remove those found not to be refugees.

  • Incorporate into Australian law those international conventions which protect people from being returned to face situations of danger in their own countries.

  • End two-year waiting period for social security entitlements.

  • Maintain current immigration levels, but with a heavier emphasis on family reunion and humanitarian intake.

Greens

  • Abolish mandatory detention.

  • Abolish three-year temporary protection visas for refugees who arrive without a visa, and grant immediate permanent residence to all those currently on temporary visas.

  • Institute reception centres to determine identity, provide health checks.

  • Institute community-based arrangements for asylum seekers while claims are being processed.

  • Broaden the term "refugee" to apply to people displaced due to famine, poverty, environmental degradation, war, political oppression and denial of human rights.

  • Restructure immigration system so it is based predominantly on family reunions and other special humanitarian criteria while recognising the importance of the skilled migration category.

  • End language discrimination, reject the requirement to be fluent in English.

  • Grant Full access to social security, legal and interpreter services, English language classes, post-trauma counselling.

  • Increase funding to immigrant service providers.

Socialist Alliance

  • Close the detention centres

  • End mandatory detention

  • Grant full rights for asylum seekers and migrants

  • Abolish the two-year waiting period which prevents newly arrived migrants accessing social security.

  • Abolish temporary protection visas.

  • End all deportations.

  • Remove all restrictive and discriminatory immigration regulations and abolish the pro-business "points" system.

  • Fund specialist services for resettlement.

  • Institute unlimited and free English classes.

  • Extend full citizenship rights including the right to vote to all refugees and migrants.

You need Green Left, and we need you!

Green Left is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.