Still no water catchment protection

Issue 

Stop CSG Illawarra released this statement on June 28.

***

After three days of debate, the “water trigger” — an amendment to the Environment Protection Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 – passed the Senate on June 19.

Coal seam gas (CSG) projects that could affect water resources will now trigger federal approval. The trigger will bring CSG projects in for consideration; a good but very limited measure that does not match the hype.

Just as we reported in March when the amendment was tabled, there is no guarantee that the amendment will stop projects that will damage water resources. This change allows the federal environment minister to stop CSG projects that will impact water, but it also allows the minister not to.

While the environment minister must now take advice from the independent expert scientific committee on CSG development before making a decision, it also makes the minister the sole decision-maker. This advice is just information to be considered.

Ministerial discretion was one of the huge problems with the contentious Part 3A: a clause in the NSW Environmental Planning and Assessment Act that granted the planning minister complete control over the approvals process, including the right to bypass environmental and local planning controls.

In short, the water trigger provides no objective, quantifiable protection.

The changes fail to define trigger points beyond an abstract definition of “significant”. “Significant” is a subjective term – the federal government needs to tell the public what they consider significant, and what they do not.

The changes do not even mention drinking water catchments, when CSG — and the industrial development and toxic risks it brings — should simply be banned in these areas.