Engels: The Che Guevara of his day

September 26, 2008

Engels: A Revolutionary Life

By John Green

Artery Publications, 2008

347 pages, £10 (pb)

Available from http://www.arterypublications.co.uk/

Most people know that Friedrich Engels (1820-1895) was the lifelong friend and collaborator of Karl Marx, and for most people the image of Engels that springs most readily to mind is of a heavily bearded, earnest old Victorian gentleman (most likely standing in the background of a group consisting of Marx and his family). In Engels: A Revolutionary Life, John Green sets out to "remove much of the historical dust, in order to reveal the man of flesh and blood hidden beneath, someone we can readily identify with and who comes alive through his passionate historical intervention".

Throughout the book Green time and again returns to comparisons between the younger Engels and Che Guevara: both rejected their comfortable backgrounds and the privileges that went along with them in order to espouse the interests of the poor and oppressed.

"In his twenties, like Che Guevara, Engels penned radical poetry and dreamed of transforming the world; he also fought with a small band of revolutionary 'guerrilleros' in the wooded hills of southern Germany against the might of the Prussian state, was placed top of its most wanted list, charged with high treason, and he was harassed and spied upon."

Like Che, Engels had a practical as well as theoretical interest in military matters (so much so that he was nicknamed "The General" by the Marx family).

Indeed, the young Engels bears a remarkable physical resemblance to Che, and the front cover of Green's biography carries a photograph of Engels in his early twenties that bears a striking resemblance to Alberto Korda's famous photograph of Che.

Usually, historical biographies are written in the past tense, but Green has chosen to write this biography in the present tense in order to "communicate the immediacy of his life and the revolutionary events that accompanied it in a more intimate way than the distancing past tense could have done". Green does this very successfully, and the picture that emerges is indeed of a "principled and passionate man whose every action was taken on behalf of his fellow human beings".

The Engels of flesh and blood emerges too: we hear how after the failure of the 1848 European revolutions the 28-year-old Engels walked the 500km from Paris to Switzerland. He reacted to being called a "bloody foreigner" by a man in a Manchester pub by hitting him over the head with an umbrella. Green also tells of Engels' relationship with the near-illiterate Irish factory worker Mary Burns, and — following Mary's death — with her sister Lizzie.

In addition to providing a compelling portrait of Engels the man, Green also sets the record straight on the contribution Engels made to the development of modern socialism. It is common nowadays to hear Engels characterised as a crude simplifier, or perhaps even falsifier, of Marx's views.

Green counters this by reminding us that not only did Engels take on the gargantuan task of turning the mass of near illegible notes left by Marx after his death into the second and third volumes of Capital, he was also responsible for pointing Marx in the direction of political economy in the first place.

Green explains the pivotal importance in the development of Marx's own thinking of Engels' 1844 essay "Outlines of a Critique of National Economy" and 1845 book The Condition of the Working Class in England. The latter is described by Karl Kautsky as "the beginning of theoretical socialism", and "even in the area where Marx achieves his greatest fulfilment — political economy — it is Engels who, certainly to begin with, is very much the feeder. It is undoubtedly he also who pushes Marx in the direction of investigating the role of private property and the contradiction between the humane phraseology of capitalism's apologists and the inhumane practice of the free market system. It is Engels who explains to him how economic crises occur and the minutiae of capital accumulation and concentration."

Indeed, Marx himself says to Engels in a letter from the mid-1860s that "I am always following in your footsteps".

In addition to the intellectual contribution Engels made to the development of Marx's thought, Green reminds us that for 20 years Engels held down a desk job that he hated in order to finance not only Marx and his family, but a number of other socialists and socialist organisations.

Engels: A Revolutionary Life is an excellent book, clearly written and an enjoyable read. Green brings Engels and his work vividly to life, and in doing so he has done the labour movement an enormous service. This book deserves a wide readership and a place on any progressive reader's bookshelves.

[A longer version of this review first appeared at http://www.links.org.au]

You need Green Left, and we need you!

Green Left is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.