New Zealand: Maori MP refuses oath to queen

July 23, 2011
Hone Harawiri reading his oath to parliament, which swore allegience to the Maori-British treaty rather than the English queen.

Hone Harawira, an elected member of New Zealand parliament for the newly formed Mana Party, caused a stir on July 14 when he refused to swear allegiance to the English queen in order to take his seat.

Instead, Harawiri swore allegiance, in Maori, to Te Tiriti o Waitangi (the 1840 treaty between Maori tribes and Britain that recognised Maori ownership of their lands.) said that day that parliamentary speaker Lockwood Smith refused to swear Harawira in as an MP on the grounds his affirmation was not legal.

“As Harawira left the debating chamber, supporters sung from the public galleries in defiance of Smith's ruling for them to cease,” the article said.

“Outside Parliament a large crowd of supporters gathered to perform a haka as Harawira prepared to address them clad in a traditional feather cloak.”

By refusing to swear an oath to the queen, Harawira was fulfilling an election promise in the June 25 Te Tai Tokerau by-election.

Harawira first won the Te Tai Tokerau seat as a member of the Maori Party in 2005, but he left the party over its deals with the right-wing National Party government.

The Mana Party was formed in April on a platform of Maori liberation and workers' rights.

Joe Carolan, a member of the Mana Party in Auckland, campaigns organiser for the Unite union and editor of, told Green Left Weekly: “The reality is New Zealand is a colonial state and was founded on theft of Maori land and murder of Maori people.

“For parliament to force a representative of Maori people to swear allegiance to the queen before his own people or before New Zealand's founding document ― the treaty ― it is a huge insult.

Carolan said Harawira's stance “began a big national debate about archaic institutions such as the monarchy and the class society it represents, as well as an Anglo-centric culture that is not in touch with 21st century working-class reality in New Zealand”.

“It also demonstrated how the Mana Party intends to conduct its business in the capitalist parliament. How we start is how we intend to continue.”

Carolan said the Mana Party's approach to parliament could be summed up in the argument of Irish socialist republican James Connolly: The capitalist parliament is a dungheap from the top of which you can blow the trumpet of freedom.

“To be thrown out of parliament within three minutes of entering the place must be a world record for a radical left-wing party. It shows the fear and contempt the establishment holds us in.

“This is how we intend to use parliament ― to be disturbers of the peace, as Connolly said.

“We are proud of Honi for his stance.”

In the November elections, the party is looking to get its vice presidents ― veteran activist John Minto and radical lawyer Annette Sykes ― elected to join Harawira.

Carolan told Green Left Weekly: “What is apparent [in NZ politics] is a gap on the left. The Labour Party has plummeted to all time low of 27%.”

In power, Labour has attacked workers' living standards, sold off public assets and introduced the goods and services tax.

Carolan said, in contrast, Mana was committed to abolishing the GST, taking the rich and achieving full employment.

“We want to use the billions used to bailout finance to create full-time jobs on living wage for all.”

“We are here to fundamentally change New Zealand,” Carolan said. “We are not fucking around.”


Go the Mana Party you have in my estamation the support of all a large hunk of the voice who dont paticipate in any polling - that is why polling in respect to the support of which ever party is a misnoma - Go Hone Annette John and everyone else who supports real equality -By the way Hone I live on a busy street you can put your Promo Party Boards on our fence. Also I have no idea why there isnt rage about this milionaire and others making such huge profit and not paying task all those loop holes should be shut down. Tax companies taking there factories out of NZ for cheeper labour and exploitation of the poor in 3rd world countries. There should be a ,sealing on technology introduced into our factories, wdhen you make someone unemployed you make their families UNEMPLOYED - who do I blame....the POLITICIANS are in my view the blame for everything that is bad in our communities, when do they get held accountable for the policies they pass that have huge implications on the families already doing it hard.
This article is almost entirely false. He didn't ever refuse to swear an oath to the queen. He only wanted to swear an oath to Maori, New Zealanders, Te Tiriti and Te Tai Tokerau first, after that he planned to swear the legal affirmation as well. His affirmation was completely legal. There is nothing in the Constitution Act (1986) that says he cannot add extra to his oath, so long as he says those exact words as well. In fact, the same speaker allowed him to say exactly what he wanted to say this time in 2008 and the speaker before that in 2005. Many other MPs have also been able to do similar things. Although I have no way of knowing for sure, I and many others believe that this was Lockwood Smith's reaction to a racist Act Party ad entitled, "Fed Up With Pandering to Maori Radicals?" I also peronally believe that Lockwood Smith did this because Hone Harawira is no longer in coalition with the National Party. This article does not do justice to Hone.

You need Green Left, and we need you!

Green Left is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.