Pro-queer Muslims challenge prejudice

March 12, 2011
Muslims Against Homophobia float, Mardi Gras, Sydney. Photo: Alice Aslan

This year’s Sydney Mardi Gras gave many people the opportunity to say something about the issues that concern lesbian, gay, bisexual, intersex and transgendered (LGTBI) people. Most floats in the parade voiced their support for same-sex marriage.

Muslims Against Homophobia, a recently-formed support group for queer Muslims in Sydney, made a groundbreaking appearance in the parade. It said something equally important and urgent: “Queer Muslims need acceptance!”

There is much stigma attached to homosexuality in Muslim societies. In some Muslim nations homosexuality is still criminalised, and is even punishable by death in some, such as Saudi Arabia and Iran.

In the past, most Muslim societies were sexually permissive, and were even viewed as lascivious by colonial Western nations.

Some Muslim countries, especially those in the Middle East, had a widespread homosexual culture that tolerated sexual relationships between men.

But the moralistic colonial authorities, mostly strict Christians, disapproved of sex between men and banned it. More recently, with the rise of harsher forms of Islam in conservative Muslim circles, homosexuality is now viewed mostly as a sign of Western decadence that poisons Muslims.

Most Muslim societies do not recognise homosexuality as a different identity, but what they generally stigmatise and criminalise is sexual intercourse between men.

There are many social and political obstacles, which make it hard and impractical to advocate queer rights in these conservative societies, where different identities and subcultures can’t usually freely flourish.

Although sex is a natural part of life according to Islam (unlike Christianity, which traditionally promoted celibacy) it is generally strictly regulated to take place only between married heterosexual couples.

The most important obstacles of all are the repressive regimes in most Muslim countries, which do not provide mainstream people with rights and freedoms, let alone minorities like queer people.

But despite this gloomy picture, homosexuals in these countries, which don’t usually allow their people to express their diverse identities honestly and freely, generally live in secrecy and network quietly - unlike out-and-proud Western homosexuals.

They avoid getting into trouble by leading a double life, some managing a heterosexual marriage and a same-sex relationship at the same time.

In Turkey, a secular and more liberal Muslim country, Istanbul’s homosexual community has a pride week and a gay and lesbian parade in late June every year as part of a niche counter culture.

Homosexual rights in Muslim countries will be probably achieved as part of a general struggle for civil rights in these nations — just like the civil rights movement in the US in 1960s, which also triggered the homosexual rights movement.

But progressive-minded Muslims can also make a difference. For instance, today some Muslim scholars like Scott Kugle interpret the Koran in a progressive way to include and accept different groups like homosexuals.

Groups such as the US-based Al-Fatiha (, an organisation that promotes acceptance and justice for queer Muslims, also have an important role to play.

On the other hand, just like the headscarf issue, the ideological use of Islamic homophobia by some hostile Western groups to demonstrate that Muslim societies and communities are less civilised and incompatible with Western values doesn’t help queer Muslims, but only exacerbates Islamophobia.

However, Western groups, in particular Western queer groups, can make a difference by genuinely understanding the specific needs and circumstances of different Muslim homosexual groups and by cooperating with them to promote homosexual rights.

As Arab-Australian scholar Samar Habib points out, most queer Muslims in Australia are very reluctant to talk in public about their real identity since most of them are still in the closet to their families, unlike those in the US and Canada who have come out.

The lack of any gay-support groups makes this harder.

Muslims Against Homophobia aims to fill this gap and establish a generous platform to support queer Muslims in Australia, inspiring progressive Muslims everywhere to speak out against homophobia. This is the only way to make a real difference!

[Alice Aslan is a Sydney-based writer and social anthropologist. She is the author of Islamophobia in Australia and formed Muslims Against Homophobia, which proudly took part in the March 5 Sydney Mardi Gras Parade for the first time.]


The Koran explicitly prohibits homosexual acts so I'm not sure where do you get you get the idea that the Christians are to blame, or even why this is relevant. The treatment of homosexuals in the Islamic world ranges from social and familial ostracism, arrest accompanied by beatings and/or torture, forced sex change operations, floggings, all the way through to execution. So why should liberated homosexuals in the West not be entitled to feel a bit Islamophobic? Islamophobia doesn't mean the fear of a woman forced to wear a veil, or of a repressed gay Muslim, it is the fear of the ideology that oppresses them. You can argue that there is a more liberated, or tolerant version of Islam that doesn't discriminate against LGBTs, but where is the evidence of this? Turkey has been one country to (unofficially) treat LGBTs less harshly because it has (until recently) had a strong secular state, which has been able to defend more liberal values against Islamic conservatism. Its attempts to accede to the EU has also helped at an institutional level. But the only true legal safe haven for LGBTs in the Middle East is Israel, which is where many gay Arabs end up seeking refuge. I am increasingly baffled by the moral contortions some on the left put themselves through in order to defend Islam, even when the values it espouses appear to radically conflict with their own, and are often sexist, racist, homophobic and intolerant of other beliefs. It is not as though they would would do this on behalf of Catholicism, for example. Is it that someone else's religious conservatism is somehow more exotic? Or is it that it appears to share a common enemy in the USA, and its materialist, capitalist ideology? Either way its a great mistake to unthinkingly embrace what is not simply spiritual and introspective, but a political ideology with earthly ambitions, and deeply-held values that are in conflict with our own.
Are you completely mad? Homosexuality in Iran is punishable by death,Gaza gays are beaten and killed as regulary as young girls are honour murdered. The Koran specifically calls for the death of male homosexuals-please feel free to organise a gay pride parade in gaza-I'll send flowers to your funeral!
and only one of the two prepared to show her face. I take it that's the author of the article?

You need Green Left, and we need you!

Green Left is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.