Boycotting Israel: the threat of a good example

Issue 
Peter Slezak.

Below is an address to Marrickville Council meeting on BDS by Dr. Peter Slezak, associate professor in history and philosophy at the University of New South Wales, arguing against a motion on April 19 to rescind the council’s support for the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) campaign against Israel.

***

Not long ago, moral opposition to the Vietnam War and opposition to our complicity in the crimes in East Timor received the same denunciation we witness now against Marrickville council.

Why would you abandon a largely symbolic policy of ethical investment and spending just because the usual suspects — Murdoch press, the government and the Israel lobby — give you a hard time?

This extraordinary campaign of vilification of Mayor Fiona Byrne and Marrickville councillors means that you are doing something right — and something important.

Since the real effect of a council BDS is not going to bring down the state of Israel, it’s important to understand what is perceived to be the threat that has unleashed this orchestrated campaign of denigration and abuse. It’s the threat of a good example.

This is the example of decent people taking a stand for justice, human rights and international law — through peaceful means — by exercising their choice of where to invest and spend their money.

This is not engaging in foreign affairs or bringing distant conflict to Australia, as critics keep repeating. It is acting locally to raise consciousness and to put pressure on our federal government. That’s what decent citizens do.

The point was made elegantly in a letter to the Sydney Morning Herald: “Of course Marrickville council should not be boycotting Israel. The federal government should be.”



If a protest for justice and human rights is supposed to bring foreign affairs into local communities, what are we to say about the many Zionist organisations such as the Jewish National Fund that send immense funds to the state of Israel in support of its discriminatory policies, the expropriation of Palestinian land, its military occupation and siege of Gaza?

In a different sense, however, the issue has, indeed, become more than a local matter. Letters of support show that the whole world is watching Marrickville to see whether it has the courage and the decency to withstand the predictable bullying from the predictable sources.

Marrickville Council has taken a lead and set a moral example. What is “nuts” about that — to quote foreign minister Kevin Rudd? What is “extremist” about that — to quote [Australian journalist] Greg Sheridan? And what term is appropriate for those who support the crimes of the state of Israel?

A 40-year, brutal military occupation, half a million illegal settlers, the theft of Palestinian land, the illegal separation wall on Palestinian land, thousands of home demolitions, regular shooting of unarmed non-violent demonstrators, and the collective punishment of Gaza in violation of international law.

Who are the extremists? Those who support all this or those who support justice and human rights through peaceful BDS protest?

You have the opportunity tonight in the eyes of the world to remain principled and resolute, or to look foolish and cowardly. If you rescind the BDS policy, you will lose the respect of those you have inspired here and around the world, but you will get no thanks, just contempt, from your detractors.

Councillors who opposed the original BDS resolution should now stand up for it in the face of the vicious attacks.

It’s not just a question of BDS, but also a question of the kind of society we should tolerate. To cave in to the intimidation would prove that vilification and bullying can silence moral protest.

Crucially, you must not tolerate, or be silenced by, the disgraceful charge of anti-Semitism levelled at decent people who criticize the state of Israel.

I speak as a Jew whose parents survived the Holocaust. My mother and grandmother were in Auschwitz.

Jews have a special obligation in this case to stand up for the victims of oppression and against violence committed in their name. That’s exactly why growing numbers of Jews here and around the world are speaking out in support of Palestinians.

With these Jews and so many others, Marrickville council should have the courage to uphold its stand, which is decent and just.

Resist the denigration so that your example can inspire others to help make a difference. Don’t let your fellow citizens down and, above all, don’t let the Palestinians down by abandoning or weakening your exemplary BDS campaign.

Comments

Dear Peter,

I am not a member of "The Murdoch Press", "The Israel Lobby", "The International Zionist Conspiracy", the "Government", or affiliated with any other political or religious organization. I'm not even Jewish.

Yet I'm sick to death of hearing this type of high minded rhetorical cliches, accompanied by accusations of "Zionist" conspiracy theories substitute for reasoned argument. We had this before in Germany in the 1930's - and that wasn't the first time. Instead why don't you show us some reasoned evidence that Israel is a satanic nation that must be destroyed for the sake of the rest of humanity. No doubt the "Murdoch Press", etc will have no choice but to go along or self-destruct in a puff of logic and the BDS will be enacted for the good of all...

Palestinians do not have a special place above Australians, the people of Marrickville do not need to live in local fear because of over seas issues.
Local people need to have our local needs looked after by our local council, international issues can be looked after by our federal members.
The BDS is now dead in the water in Australia, any other people that love Palestine so much "no one is stopping you from moving"

please. "satanic" nation? "must be destroyed for the sake of the rest of humanity"? Who said that?

Same usual rubbish from Israel defenders. The Israeli state is set up on apartheid, colonial lines that disposesses the Palestinian people. Now they are conducting ethnic cleansing against Palestine. There's no conspiracy theory, just facts.

The Israeli state is set up on apartheid, colonial lines that dispossesses the Palestinian people. Now they are conducting ethnic cleansing against Palestine. There's no conspiracy theory, just facts.
International pressure eventually stopped apartheit in South Africa. People of conscience need to do the same for the Palestinians.
STAND UP for what is right!
..not anti semetic, pro justice..
Jews have a special obligation in this case to stand up for the victims of oppression and against violence committed in their name. That’s exactly why growing numbers of Jews here and around the world are speaking out in support of Palestinians

"The Israeli state is set up on apartheid, colonial lines that dispossesses the Palestinian people. Now they are conducting ethnic cleansing against Palestine. There's no conspiracy theory, just facts."

That's not facts, just mindless rhetoric.

"That’s exactly why growing numbers of Jews here and around the world are speaking out in support of Palestinians"

No its just that many of them have a conscience, and have made an effort to understand the myriad of views on complex moral issues. Unlike the typical pro-BDS supporter, who simply parrots empty rhetorical statements thoughtfully pre-packaged for them by Israel's most militant opponents.

And while its true that most Jews do support an independent - and thriving - Palestinian state, very few support BDS.

Become a Green Left supporter today and get the first month free!

Green Left aims to make all content available online, without paywalls. We rely on regular support and donations from readers like you.

Any reader who becomes a $5, $10 or $20 per month supporter between August 3 and 11 will get the first month free.