Battle for ‘rare earths’ heats up

'Rare earth' metals are used in laser technology as well as other modern electronic products.

The battle for the planet’s dwindling resources has taken a further trade war twist with China’s recent decision to place limits on the export of the 17 chemical elements collectively known as “rare earths”.

These elements, found near the bottom of the periodic table, are crucial for manufacture of a wide range of modern technology products.

These include superconductors, magnets used in wind turbines, catalysts for electric cars, electronic polishing for optical products, laser technology, fibre optics, cathode ray tubs, microwaves, and — less usefully perhaps — iPhones and flat-screen TVs.

China gained a virtual monopoly of the “rare earth” market during the 1990s, stepping up production and driving down world prices. This put other mining operations out of business.

Now, China controls up to 97% of the market.

Rare earths are not found in high concentrations — you have to move a lot of earth to get at them. The extraction process produces radioactive slurry. Toxic acids are used in refining.

The Chinese government’s mining operation in inner Mongolia, has caused major damage to the environment.

If the Chinese continue to limit exports, there will be a rush to restart elsewhere. In fact, the Mountain Pass mine in California — closed since 2002 — will re-open next year with new owners. There are also plans for a big operation in Canada.

Shares in rare metal mining companies have soared in recent months.

Some of the rare earth elements are becoming harder to come by, even in China — and the pressure to mine all known deposits is growing. The reality is that the world is running out of some of the most crucial chemical elements.

There is a growing shortage of Helium-3, an inert gas that is a by-product of radioactive decay. It is used in cryogenics, medical imaging research, and radiation detection devices.

Stocks are dwindling while demand soars as a result of its use in security scanners. The “war on terror” is actually threatening cancer research rather than terrorists.

There is about 10 years supply left of the elements indium and hafnium, thanks to the manufacture of flat-screen TVs. Both are essential for solar cells and computer chips.

A recent United Nations report called for urgent expansion of recycling of speciality metals. Thomas Graedel, the leader of the working group which is assessing world supply, warned in May: “Scientists should anticipate the possibility that they may not have the whole periodic table to work with in future.

“Except for the major base metals and a couple of the most valuable metals, rates of recycling for almost all metals in the periodic table are low. That means that they will be used one time and discarded, and that’s a non-sustainable approach.”

But sustainability is the last thing on the mining corporations’ minds. Extracting metals in useable form from manufactured products is expensive. Extraction of the raw material in low-wage economies is cheap and controls are few.

The only long-term and sustainable solution is to shift from profit-driven manufacture to needs-driven production, where valuable elements are kept for use in essential products.

[Abridged from]